Pilasters
Pilasters can best be described as rectangular versions of columns attached to a wall. Chambers describes them as being proportioned and decorated in the same manner with the columns
and differ from columns in their plan only; wihich is square, as that of the column is round. Their bases, capitals and entablatures, have the same parts, with all the same heights and projections, as those of columns, and they are distinguished in the same manner, by the names of Tuscan, Doric, Ionic, Composite, and Corinthian.
In this chapter, I will:
- Adapt the Tuscan Order profiles to form a pilaster order comprising pedestal, column & entablature
- Show different ways to overcome the problem of handling the Ionic, Corinthian ∓ Composite capitals when transitioning to the square form of the pilaster from the round form of the column
- and, Explain using the pedestal & entablature profiles to add classical elements to an existing wall or building (and how to handle repeating elements like the dentils of the entablature)
Some Notes on Pilasters
Before we get started, there are just a few areas I want to cover about how pilasters differ from columns, and some issues they cause and possible solutions.
Applying Diminution to Pilasters
On the question of Pilasters, there seems to be a great deal of disagreement on whether Pilasters should be diminished like Columns, or left undiminished with the Capitals enlarged accordingly.
Chambers notes that Scamozzi always gave to his pilasters the same diminution as to his columns
, and mentions Inigo Jones doing so at the Banqueting House as well, while at the same time noting that Palladio, Vignola, Inigo Jones, and many of the greatest architects
executed Pilasters without any diminution. He concludes by saying Nevertheless it is certain that diminished pilasters are on many accounts much preferable
.
Batty Langley perhaps gave the simplest statement: when pilasters are used with columns, their shafts must have the same diminution as the columns, but when they are used alone, they should not be diminished
.
What he doesn’t say, however, is whether they should be diminished both in depth as well as in width. Perrault (who agrees with Chambers on this in general) adds that when they are in line with columns we must give the pilaster the same diminution as the column, but this applies only to its front face, since the sides are left without diminution, as they are on the Temples of Antoninus and of Faustina.
What he refers to is described by Desgodets: The Pilaster on the outward face does not diminish like the Columns, being full two modules in width at the fillet immediately under the Capital, but the side which faced the Columns was diminished like the columns, in order to support duly the Architrave which passed over both the Columns and the Pilasters.
.
Therefore, the steps below will assume that diminution is applied to the pilaster only on the front view (by which I mean when looked at from the front, the sides will diminish upwards, but when looked at from the side, the pilaster will project an equal amount from the wall all the way up the shaft).
Entasis & Pilasters
With regard to entasis, while there is disagreement about Diminution, I can’t find any specific references to Entasis ever being applied to Pilasters by any authority I have consulted.
However, there are two references that might be presumed to indicate it should by applied. The first is where Chambers refers to Pilasters as being proportioned and decorated in the same manner with the columns
, and pilasters differ from columns in their plan only, which is square, as that of the column is round.
And, the second is the quote above by Langley, which could indicate pilasters used with columns should have entasis applied to completely match the look of columns. However, in both instances the authorities don’t specifically mention entasis anywhere, so I am not certain this would apply. However, a problem with this is Chambers certainly does not use the word entasis, only diminution, so when he mentions diminution he could also be referring to the curve not just the diminishing diameter.
However, as there is no solid evidence (and it does not seem logical to apply it to a surface placed against a flat wall), the steps below will assume that Entasis will not be applied, only diminution.
Projection of Pilasters
Whether Pilasters are diminished or not, there is the question of how far they project out from the wall. This seems to be determined not only by the Authority you follow, but also the use and placement of the Pilasters.
Chambers, Le Clerc, Perrault, & Ware all go into detail regarding the handling of pilsters, so for more information you can read these or the authority of your choice.
Just note, that for the sake of the examples below, I am assuming the Pilaster will project they should project one quarter of their diameter beyond the walls, as Scamozzi teaches
.
The Tuscan Pilaster Order
As quoted above, Chambers notes that Pilasters differ from columns in their plan only, which is square, as that of the column is round. Their bases, capitals and entablatures, have the same parts, with all the same heights and projections, as those of columns
. As a result, the profiles used for the columns will serve as the basis for generating the pilaster order profiles, so the below instructions assume all the profiles needed to make the column order have already been created.
The steps in forming the pilaster order will differ from that of the column, as the pilaster itself will be created first, then the pedestal and entablature. The reason for this is that both of the latter can be used in a linear running fashion along a wall, while the pilaster, though attached to the wall, is still a separate element. Indeed, where the pedestal and entablature are concerned, the pilaster itself can simply be thought of as a forward break in the wall, which is exactly how the cores of both elements will be created.
Creating the Pilaster Profiles
- Unhide the
Column-Shaft-profile , copy it into memory, hide it again, Paste-in-Place, Make Unique, and renamePilaster-Shaft-Diminished-profile - Open the component, erase the arc forming the outer edge of the profile, and replace with a line connecting the endpoints of the two congé moldings (to replace the entasis with simple diminution), then close the component
- Select the component, copy it into memory, hide the original, Paste-in-Place, Make Unique, and rename
Pilaster-Shaft-QuarterProjection-profile - Open the component, select the top right area of the profile (containing the astragal, fillet & congé), and move them 5 min to the right on the Red Axis (to remove diminution from this profile), then select the entire right side of the profile and move it 15 min to the left on the Red Axis (which will set the projection from the wall to be
1/4 of the diameter), then close the component - Copy the
Pilaster-Shaft-QuarterProjection-profile into memory, hide the original, Paste-in-Place, and Make Unique (for temporary use) - Rotate the component 90 degrees clockwise towards the front, using the Centerline as the pivot
- Open the component, join any divided arcs with the Weld extension, and use Push/Pull to extrude the face out about 60 min to the left and right (to make sure it spans the pilaster width), then close and hide the component
- Unhide the
Pilaster-Shaft-Diminished-profile , copy it into memory, hide the original, Paste-in-Place, Make Unique, and rename (I just remove ‘profile#1’ from the name) - Open the component, and join any divided arcs with the Weld extension
- Next, select all, and rotate/copy the geometry 180 degrees clockwise centered on the Centerline, then reverse the face of the rotated side, and erase the line running through the new center, and use Weld again on the top edge to join the two segments together
- Now use Push/Pull to pull the face out towards the front about 60 min, then close the component
- Unhide the
Pilaster-Shaft-QuarterProjection-profile#1 , cut it into memory, open thePilaster-Shaft-Diminished , Paste-in-Place, then explode the pasted component - Then select all, Right-click, and choose Intersect Faces With Selection
- Double-click on the three ‘profile faces’ that extend beyond the intersecting geometry at the left, front and right, and delete them, followed by the lines remaining from their sides
- Check over the resulting geometry, and erase any lines that are remaining on faces where they should not be located, and hide any lines that are not supposed to be seen, then close the component
- Unhide the
Column-Base-Plinth-profile andColumn-Base-Torus-profile , copy them, hide the originals, Paste-in-Place, and create new componentPilaster-Base - Open the new component, explode the two original components, erase the line running therough the center, and use Weld to join any separate arcs together
- With the
Pilaster-Shaft-Diminished still open, draw a line, from it’s rear right corner, downwards on the Blue Axis to the bottom of the base, then erase the geometry to the left of the line just drawn, and draw three lines over the edges of the front and sides of the bottom of the pilaster shaft - Select the three lines just drawn (outlining the exterior of the pilaster shaft), and use Follow-Me on the face of the base, then close the component
- Unhide the
Column-Capital-Abacus-profile andColumn-Capital-Ovolo-profile , copy them, hide the originals, Paste-in-Place, and create new componentPilaster-Capital - Draw a line, on the top of the
Pilaster-Shaft-Diminished , starting from the bottom right corner of the new component, coming forward 15 min on the Green Axis, then going leftwards 50 min towards & past the Centerline, then backwards 15 min on the Green Axis, then cut the three lines into memory - Open the new component, explode the two original components, erase the line running therough the center, and use Weld to join any separate arcs together
- Draw a line, starting a short distance to the left of the bottom right corner of the capital, going up to the top of the capital, then erase all the geometry to the left of that line
- Paste-in-Place the lines copied earlier, and use Follow-Me on the face of the capital, then close the component
- Select the
Pilaster-Base ,Pilaster-Shaft-Diminished &Pilaster-Capital , and make a new componentPilaster-standalone
The Pilaster Shaft Profiles
Two profiles will be created for the pilaster shaft in order to take into account the issue of diminution that gets applied here.
Therefore the pilaster shaft needs to have entasis removed, and also have profiles both for the front and side (to accommodate the diminished and non-diminished aspects).
Forming the Pilaster Elements
The following steps are arranged in order of ease, not the same order as was used in forming the column.
The Pilaster Shaft
The Pilaster Base
The Pilaster Capital
The Full Pilaster
The Pedestal & Entablature for the Pilaster
The steps to form these components are similar to those used for the standalone column pedestal and entablature, just customized for the pilaster.
<&>See Wrapping a Molding Profile around a Core (Or Path) on page ... for a refresher.- Unhide the
Pedestal-Base-Molding-profile andPedestal-Cap-Molding-profile , copy them into memory, hide the originals, Paste-in-Place, Make Unique, and Rename (I just add ‘Pilaster’ before ‘Pedestal’ and remove ‘profile#1’ from the end) - With the
Pilaster-standalone visible, draw a rectangle around the bottom of the base, use Push/Pull to extend the face down to the bottom of the pedestal base molding component, then Triple-click and make a componentPilaster-Pedestal-Die-Core , and hide thePilaster-standalone - Open the
Pilaster-Pedestal-Cap-Molding , draw lines around the front and two sides of the top of the pedestal die, select them, then use Follow-Me on the face of the molding, then close the component - Repeat the above for the
Pilaster-Pedestal-Base-Molding , except draw lines around the bottom of the die and hide the top edges of the congé molding before closing the component - Select the
Pilaster-Pedestal-Die-Core ,Pilaster-Pedestal-Cap-Molding &Pilaster-Pedestal-Base-Molding and make a new componentPilaster-Pedestal-standalone - Unhide the
Entablature-Architrave-Molding-profile ,Entablature-Cornice-Molding-profile &Entablature-Frieze-Core-profile , copy them into memory, hide the originals, Paste-in-Place, and Make Unique, and rename (I just add ‘Pilaster’ before ‘Entablature’ and remove ‘profile#1’ from the end) - As the pilaster is not diminished in depth, the entablature core will project out 15 min, so open the
Pilaster-Entablature-Frieze-Core , select all, and rotate/copy the geometry 180 degrees clockwise on the Centerline, reverse the rotated face, erase the center line, and Push/Pull the face out 15 min, and close the component - Now, just like for the pedestal, open each of the molding copies, draw lines around the frieze edges, select them and use them as the path for the Follow-Me tool to wrap the moldings around
- Select the
Pilaster-Entablature-Architrave-Molding ,Pilaster-Entablature-Cornice-Molding andPilaster-Entablature-Frieze-Core and join them into a new componentPilaster-Entablature-standalone - Unhide the
Pilaster-standalone to see the three pilaster components together
The Pedestal for the Pilaster
For this, the molding profiles will be reused, but the die core will be recreated, as it is just easier due to the geometry involved.The Entablature for the Pilaster
The steps here are similar to that for the pedestal, but in this case it is easiest to use the existing frieze core, along with the molding profiles.The Complete Pilaster Order
The Running Pedestal and Entablature
There are two ways that can these components can be created, for two different scenarios. Although I will illustrate them separately, they could be used for either component as necessary.
The Running Tuscan Pedestal
If you want the pedestal moldings to stretch along a wall or around a room simply follow the steps above, but instead of wrapping the moldings just around the die you would select all the edges on the wall where you needed them to appear.
If you were using these moldings as just a baseboard and chair rail you could select just the walls for your path. However, if you are including pilasters, you would place your pedestal dies and then wrap around both wall and die at the same time.
The Running Tuscan Entablature
To utilize the entablature so they span multiple columns, place a copy of your profile in the proper position that you need and simply Push/Pull the core profile the desired length, then repeat the steps for Wrapping a Molding Profile Around a Core (or Path) in the Appendix.
The Doric Pilaster Order
The Doric pilaster order can be created in much the same way as the Tuscan pilaster order, as the only structural difference would be in accounting for the repeating elements of the entablature. Just as with the Tuscan order, creating the pilaster assumes all the profiles needed to make the Doric order have already been created.Creating the Pilaster Profiles
Just as with the Tuscan pilaster, only diminished and non-diminished profiles for the shaft need to be created here.The Pilaster Shaft Profiles
Just as with the Tuscan pilaster order, diminution will be applied to the sides of the shaft while the depth remains a constant 1/4 diameter out from the wall. The Doric pilaster shaft profiles can be created the same exact way as the Tuscan pilaster profiles. <&>See the The Pilaster Shaft Profiles in the section The Tuscan Pilaster Order in the chapter The Tuscan Order on page … for a refresher. When you are done, you should have theForming the Pilaster Elements
The Doric pilaster shaft, base and capital can all be created almost the same as for the Tuscan pilaster order, except for slight changes due to the added complexity of the base and capital elements.The Pilaster Shaft
The pilaster can be formed exactly the same as for the Tuscan order. <&>See the Forming the Pilaster Elements in the section The Tuscan Pilaster Order in the chapter The Tuscan Order on page … for a refresher. When you are done, you should have theThe Pilaster Base
The Doric pilaster base can be formed much the same as for the Tuscan, but here you will be using theThe Pilaster Capital
Just as for the base, there are slight differences when forming the pilaster capital.The Pedestal & Entablature for the Pilaster
The steps to form the pedestal will match those for the Tuscan order, but additional steps are needed for the Doric entablature.The Pedestal for the Pilaster
The steps to create the pedestal will be exactly the same as for the Tuscan order. When you are done you should have theThe Entablature for the Pilaster
The steps for the Doric pilaster entablature will follow those for the Tuscan, but with a few minor changes. Other than using theThe Soffit of the Doric Pilaster Entablature
Unlike the Tuscan soffit, the Doric is heavily decorated (normally, and in this example) so must be handled special just as with the column entablature.The Complete Pilaster Order
The Running Pedestal and Entablature
The Running Doric Pedestal
The running Doric pedestal (or chair rail & baseboard) can be created just like for the Tuscan order.The Running Doric Entablature
This can initally be constructed just like the Tuscan, but afterward the repeating elements will need to be handled. The placement of the repeating elements is based on the principle of intercolumniation, or spacing between columns, so specific details will be handled in the section Notes on the Use of the Orders under Intercolumniation in the chapter Conclusion. Once you know the spacing, you can simply move/copy the firstDoric Conclusion
The creation of the Mutular Doric order has introduced several new methods and practices, as well as re-using a large number from the previous chapter. This will be true for the following chapters as well, where each order, while having it’s own character and introducing new methods, is built on the same classical background as the rest. One additional note here is that there are two other cornices used in the entablatures of the Doric order. These are what might be called the Antique cornice and the Denticular cornice. The Antique cornice is the type used by the Greeks, described by Vitruvius, and shown by both Serlio and Palladio. The main difference with the Mutular is that the mutules of the Antique don’t hang down out of the soffit, but are embedded up into it. Examples of this can be found in the treatises of both Serlio and Palladio, as well as in Chambers’ treatise, where he shows an example from Palladio’s Basilica at Vicenza. The Antique cornice can easily be created following the steps in this chapter. The main change will be just to adapt the formation of the guttae on the undersides of the mutules so they are on the undersides of the soffit. The Denticular cornice is first found used in the Doric order (to my knowledge) in the Theatre of Marcellus in Rome, dating to the 1st century- The Column & Pilaster Components (as these can be used ‘as is’ so to speak)
- Un-hide the
Entablature.Dentil , copy, hide the original, and Paste-in-place The location of the component, following the instructions above, has it sitting with it’s rear midpoint on the wall plane of our pilaster, at the right edge of the dentil band.The exact arrangment of the dentils on the side of the pedestal entablature is another area where I cannot find a lot of information. The space available would allow 2 1/2 dentils, so there would be half a dentil embedded in the wall. I assume that is the norm (as the bolsters, etc., are embedded in the wall), so the below will reflect that. Just keep in mind, this is my interpretation, so if it is wrong the fault is my own, and I apologize. - Move the component forward on the Green Axis till it is even with the front of the dentil band (which should be 16 2/3 min), then move/copy it backwards 10 min twice (i.e. with 3 1/3 min separating each dentil)
The rear dentil will be embedded in the wall, so you could make this unique and reduce it to only half the width if you wish. - Now, select the frontmost dentil, rotate/copy it 90 degrees clockwise, using the corner of the dentil band as the pivot point, then move it leftwards 6 2/3 min (to position it at the corner)
- Then, move/copy it leftwards 10 min, then type x6 (to position the first copy and make 6 more across the face of the entablature)
- Finally, move/copy the three dentils on the right side over to the left side of the entablature (you can use the front left corner of the frontmost dentil as the start point and the corner of the dentil band as the endpoint, as the dentils are square)
The 10 min is gotten as the spacing between the dentils is equal to 1/2 their width, which is 6 2/3, which makes the spacing 3 1/3 min. The Complete Pilaster Order
image of completed full pilaster order The Running Pedestal and Entablature
The Running Ionic Pedestal
This pedestal (or chair rail & baseboard) can be created just like for the previous orders.The Running Ionic Entablature
This can initally be constructed just like the Tuscan, but (just like with the Doric) afterward the repeating element or dentil will need to be handled. The placement of the dentils are based on the principle of intercolumniation, or spacing between columns, so specific details will be handled in the section Notes on the Use of the Orders under Intercolumniation in the chapter Conclusion. Once you know the spacing, you can simply move/copy the firstRepeatingElements component from one point to the next, then repeat the move/copy by typing “x” and the number of moves/copies you want repeated along the wall or colonnade. Don’t know about dentil spacing in relation to pilaster depth!Ionic Conclusion
You have reached the end of the chapter on the Ionic order, but there is a lot more that could possibly be done with this order, depending on your preferences. The Antique Capital explained here is the one used by Serlio, Palladio, Vignola, and many others, and is the one Chambers shows in the main body of his chapter on the Ionic order. However, there is another capital that was frequently used after the late 16th century, and that was the ‘Angular’ (or ‘Modern’ or ‘Scamozzi’) Ionic capital, which did away with the bolsters and angled the volutes out at each of the four corners. This was popularized by Vincenzo Scamozzi, and is shown by two examples in Chambers’ treatise, one based on Scamozzi, and “another one of a very beautiful one, executed in St. Peter’s of the Vatican, probably composed by Michelangelo”. As the Composite order uses the same arrangement of Volutes, I am going to forgo any instructions for creating this form of capital here, and will provide the steps under that order. If you wish to use the Angled Capital, you should be able to easily alter the steps as needed. See ‘The Composite Order’ for details on forming the Angular Volutes. An alternative form of entablature was used by Palladio, featuring simple scrolled brackets, and Chambers shows two designs for this type of entablature in his treatise (one from the Villa Capra and one from the Basilica at Vicenza). I am not going to go into forming the whole entablature, but I have a fairly simple way of describing the form of the bracket, so will show that in the Appendix. Note: For information on the dimensions, proportions and use of the Ionic modillion, see the authority of your choice. See ‘Create the Ionic Modillion’ in The Appendix. In addition, as stated in the text, there is information on fluting the Ionic column & pilaster, as well as applying egg-and-dart and beaded decoration to the capital, in the ‘Enrichments to the Orders’ chapter. The following is the suggested list of Components to save for this order:- The Column & Pilaster Components (as these can be used ‘as is’ so to speak)
- The Pedestal & Entablature Core Profile Components (as these can be used to stretch or span between the Columns or Pilasters)
- The Pedestal & Entablature Molding Profile Components (as these can be used to wrap around standalone elements as well as existing structures, both with or without the Column & Pilaster Components)
- The Entablature Dentil Component (to be used either rotated around a standalone Entablature or arrayed down the length of a wall or building)
- The Ionic Volute Component (which can be used not only with the Antique, but with both the Angular Ionic & Composite Capitals, as well.
- The Pedestal & Entablature Core Profile Components (as these can be used to stretch or span between the Columns or Pilasters)
- The Pedestal & Entablature Molding Profile Components (as these can be used to wrap around standalone elements as well as existing structures, both with or without the Column & Pilaster Components)
- The Entablature Repeating Elements Component (to be used either rotated around a standalone Entablature or arrayed down the length of a wall or building)
- The Entablature Soffit Metope & Corner Components (to replace the Soffit of the Entablature)